Dynamic Disk: Microsoft’s Bastard Child?

DiscFirst available in Windows 2000, Dynamic Disk is feature that, among other things, can act like a software RAID. It allows you to have multiple disks appear as one, which can then include an unlimited number of volumes. This can allow you to better organize your files, improve file performance, and if the right options are used, even protect your data against loss due to drive failure. So what’s the problem?

One problem with Dynamic Disk is that it doesn’t work with all versions of Windows. Windows XP Home Edition doesn’t support them, presumably so you’ll spend more for XP Professional if you want to use the feature. Does that mean you can use it if you’re using XP Pro? Not necessarily. If you are running on a mobile computer, it’s disabled with the presumption that there aren’t multiple disks in your laptop, so you shouldn’t need it. Another limitation is the type of disk you have. Dynamic disk cannot work on Firewire, USB or removable disk (at least in earlier versions of Windows, I was able to convert a Firewire drive in Vista Ultimate). Want to use the mirror or RAID-5 features to protect your data against disk failure? That only works on Windows 2000 Server or Windows Server 2003.

What about Windows Vista? Windows Vista does work with Dynamic Disks as well. Sometimes. I think. This Microsoft Help article, about basic and dynamic disks, is said to apply to ‘all editions of Windows Vista’. This would seem to imply that dynamic disks are available to all versions. Browsing around the internet, I’ve found many stories of people who upgraded their systems to Vista only to find their dynamic disk unavailable. My best guess (since I cannot find ANY Microsoft documentation stating otherwise) is dynamic disks are only available in Vista Business, Enterprise, and Ultimate. Unless your using a laptop of course.

What’s really unfortunate is that neither the Upgrade Adviser, nor the Vista installer itself will warn you if you have a dynamic disk that won’t be readable after the upgrade. So if you’re running Windows XP Professional and have a dynamic disk, and you upgrade to Windows Vista Home Premium, you won’t be able to read the dynamic disk. The good news is that you can convert the dynamic disk back to a basic disc, the bad news is that it will erase all the data in the process (there is a hack that supposedly works if your dynamic disk doesn’t span multiple disks).

So if you’re running Vista Ultimate you can almost certainly use dynamic disks right? Maybe not. Though Ultimate understands your dynamic disk, and the Media Center software understands it, if you use Media Center Extenders, like an xBox 360, they cannot. So if you want to take a bunch of disks and put them together into one large disk where you plan to store all your videos, better think again if there’s any chance you’ll ever use an extender.

Dynamic Disks sound like a great concept. It’s to bad that marketing decisions and compatibility issues make them such a risky proposition. Sure, you might have them working fine now, but will they survive an upgrade? Could something as simple as a poorly coded hotfix deny you access to them? I’m sticking to the standard basic disks as I’d rather not find out.

12 Replies to “Dynamic Disk: Microsoft’s Bastard Child?”

  1. Hi,
    i am trying to find an answer to a problem if you could help me. i have only one drive with me which is the functional drive and that i have converted into a dynamic disk. I want to revert back to the basic disk and it does not allow. Nor does it allow any recovery. if i install the recovery disk it says ERROR. how do i get rid of the dynamic disk.

  2. I appreicate this heads up on the Dynamic Disk…of course…I read it AFTER I had a catastrophic failure of the primary drive in my computer. It’s not often a 10K Raptor drive takes a crap….but mine did….and all of a sudden I needed my backup that was setup as a Dynamic….anyways….that old 10 GIG HD in the closet got loaded with Vista and the 500 got reformatted….what a night…spent the last 12 hours working this thing….I hate computers….hahaha

  3. If we want to use dynamic disk on Windows 2000/XP/20003, It demands using the “Upgrade to dynamic disk” in Disk Management to complete conversion. However, the current Windows Vista/2008 and Windows 7 appear to advocate the usage of dynamic disk. Because, in its Disk Management it can create the dynamic volume directly on basic disk. Meanwhile, the basic disk will convert to the dynamic disk automatically after the creation. This feature will enable us to convert basic disk to dynamic more easily, and the conversion back is very cumbersome. The following describes some problems in using dynamic disk, namely the disadvantage of dynamic disk.

    For more information about Dynamic disks and Basic disks at: http://www.dynamic-disk.com/dynamic-disk-resource.html

  4. I think th?t what you posted was actually very logical.
    ?ut, c?nsider this, what iff you wer? to write a killer he?dline?
    I mean, I don’t wish to tell you how to run ?our website,
    but what if y?u added a title to maybe grab a p?rson’s
    attention? I mean Dynamic Disk: Microsoft?? Ba?tard Ch?ld?
    | ITsVISTA is kinda boring. ?ou should look at
    Yahoo’s front page ?nd not? how they c?eate news titles to get viewers to click.
    You might try adding a video or a related pic or two to grab readers ?xcited ab?ut what you’ve got
    to say. ?n my opinion, it could b?ing your posts a little bit more interesting.

    Also visit myy homepage – hack tool working (hackingworld.hackspress.net)

Leave a Reply